Indians must wake up to their civilizational identity – Jagmohan


Underneath our national emblem are inscribed the words: “Satyameva Jayate” or “Truth Alone Triumphs”. Then why is it that there is slant, slander and lies in our public discourse? The wheel in our flag is a symbol of our ancient culture. But with what respect do we look at our ancient culture these days? – Jagmohan


Flag of India


At the dawn of India’s Independence, Pandit Jawaharlal Nehru had, with resolute intensity, declared: “We would create a mighty India — mighty in thought, mighty in deeds, mighty in culture and mighty in service to humanity”. But have we done so? Have we not instead created an India which is superficial in thought, deficient in deeds, shallow in culture and poor in service to humanity?

With no less fervour and poetic passion, Nehru, in his historic speech delivered on August 14-15 midnight, had said: “At the stroke of midnight, when the world sleeps, India will awake to life and freedom. A moment comes, which comes but rarely in history, when we step from the old to the new, when an age ends, and when the soul of a nation, long suppressed, finds utterance”. Did India really wake up and give a renewed expression to her soul? Is it not true that her wakefulness has turned out to be another kind of slumber that has pushed her soul into deeper layers of suppression?

We gave ourselves a Constitution which in all earnestness resolved to make India a sovereign, socialist, secular, democratic republic. How is it that in this democratic republic, considerations of dynasty are acquiring ascendancy, sovereignty is being exercised by electing criminals to the legislatures, secularism is being practiced by taking practically every political decision on grounds of caste and creed and socialism is being brought about by creating highest income disparities in the world?

Underneath our national emblem are inscribed the words: “Satyameva Jayate”, “Truth alone triumphs”. Then why is it that there is slant, slander and lies in our public discourse? The wheel in our flag is a symbol of our ancient culture. But with what respect do we look at our ancient culture these days?

We aspired to build a clean, cohesive, creative, constructive, compassionate and committed machinery of governance. Then how is it that what we find around us is a corrupt, casual, callous and conflict-ridden machinery which is unable to cope with any of the serious challenges that confront the nation today — be they in area of subversion, terrorism or dispensation of social and economic justice? And why is the state of our complacency such that we continue to tout our eight to 10 per cent growth, forgetting all the time that this growth has benefited only four to five per cent of our population, that India still has the largest number of poor, the largest number of illiterates and the largest number of malnourished people in the world. And that in the United Nations Development Programme Human Development Index we rank miserably, at 134.

Maybe we have progressed in a few areas. But is this progress not far below our potential as well as our requirements? Have we not in the process exposed ourselves to the risk of losing our stability, integrity and even what little is left of the noble traits of our culture? Why is it that our intellectual and moral landscape is so barren today? Why are we no longer producing great reformers and conscience-keepers of the nation, such as Swami Vivekananda, Sri Aurobindo, Rabindranath Tagore, Raja Rammohan Roy and Mahadev Govind Ranade?

A key question we should be asking ourselves, after 63 years of Independence, is: Why have so many inversions emerged and why has darkness descended on a large number of areas which were intended to be lit brilliantly?

To my mind, the answer to this question is to be found in the failure of the post-1947 leadership to grasp the significance of civilisational imperatives in building Independent India in a new mould. It is civilisational values that underpin state institutions, determine the general ethos of a society and shape the attitudes and outlook of people. But the pivotal importance of these values and the need to evolve a healthy mind and soul were ignored. It was forgotten that it was not possible to establish an honest administration without an honest mind or beautiful national edifices without beautiful national instincts.

Civilisation is the sum total of social, moral and intellectual attainments of a nation over a span of time. At the turning point of our destiny, around August 1947, we should have assessed what were the positive as well as negative attainments of our civilisation during its long march of 5,000 years. We all live in the social and cultural cage that has been fabricated for us in the past, though light and fresh breeze of the present continues to reach us through the gaps in its bars. For understanding the present, we have to go to the past, and for envisioning a great future both past and present trends have to be taken into account. The great English poet T.S. Eliot had rightly said: “Time present and time past are both present in time future, and time future in time past”.

Had we looked into our ancient and worn out baggage, we would have found a number of “gems” and “jewels” tucked in corners. We would have discovered profound patterns of thought — patterns which would have brought home to us great ideas and ideals, such as those pertaining to divinity of life, unity of existence and the universe being a cosmic web in which every element is enmeshed with each other. We would have understood the importance of being a karmayogi, of doing our duty dispassionately, without having any weakness for reward. We would have also realised what made Max Mueller to say: “If I were asked under what sky the human mind has most deeply pondered over the greatest problems of life, I should point to India…. Some of the most valuable and most instructive materials in the history of man are treasured up in India, and in India only”.

All this would have not only inspired the nation but also provided it with a metaphysical base for actualisation of a healthy democracy and for attainment of a truly humanistic and service-oriented social order.

Had we proceeded on the above lines and separated the profound from the profane, and the “gems” from the “stones” in our cultural and intellectual heritage, and harmonised the ancient nobility of temper with insight provided by modern science, we would have regenerated and reinvigorated our civilisation. Such a civilisation alone could have given us the foundational values for building a new India with a new mind, a new mission and a new message. Perhaps, even now it may not be too late to attend to the civilisational imperatives and set the country on a right course.

» Jagmohan is a former governor of J&K and a former Union minister.

One response to “Indians must wake up to their civilizational identity – Jagmohan

  1. Indian Catholics Want Action After Lawmaker’s Remarks
    By ANTO AKKARA
    Source: Catholic News Service
    Published: Friday, August 20, 2010

    BANGALORE, India (CNS)—Indian Catholic officials have demanded action against a legislator in Karnataka state for publicly urging people to “weed out Christianity” from the country.

    “The government should take exemplary action against him. It reflects poorly on the government,” Archbishop Bernard Moras of Bangalore, chairman of the Karnataka regional bishops’ council, told Catholic News Service Aug. 18 after faxing protest letters to the state governor, chief minister and National Human Rights Commission.

    Prahlad Remani, a legislator from Khanapur and a member of the pro-Hindu Bharatiya Janata Party, known as BJP, said during an Aug. 15 Indian Independence Day celebration: “People must remain watchful about the spread of these seeds of Christianity, and followers of any religion, including Hindus and others, must weed out Christianity. … If these seeds spread, then our nation will be under danger.”

    Remani was quoted by a local daily lambasting Christianity as a “foreign” faith.

    Nearly 5,000 Christians marched through Khanapur Aug. 18 “to protest the speech degrading Indian Christians and questioning their patriotism,” said Father Luis Gonsalves, a Belgaum diocesan priest who coordinated the protests. He told CNS that dozens of Hindus and Muslims also joined in the nearly two-mile march to a local government office.

    “Unless the government takes proper action on our complaint, we will be forced to undertake more protests,” said Father Gonsalves.

    In his letter, Archbishop Moras pointed out that even after the controversy broke out, Remani reiterated to the media that he “stands by his statement, and his commitment to weeding out Christians will continue by the way of a campaign against Christians.”

    “Christians are an integral part and parcel of this country. Nobody can question our patriotism,” the archbishop said.

    Christianity in India is traced to St. Thomas the Apostle, who is said to have arrived on the coast of southern Kerala state in A.D. 52 in the company of spice merchants from the Middle East.

    “It is absolutely deplorable for an elected representative to make such an inflammatory speech and, too, on Independence Day,” Father Babu Joseph, spokesman for the Catholic Bishops’ Conference of India, told CNS.

    Father Joseph said the bishops’ conference was “already exploring legal and other options.”

    “Stringent punishment should be handed out in this case to ensure that people who swear by the constitution to promote harmony do not dare to call for weeding out a community,” he added.